Comprehensive assessment of SARS-CoV-2-reactive antibodies in human milk to determine their potential as a COVID-19 therapeutic and as a means to prevent infection of breastfed babies
My work on the milk immune response to influenza vaccine translated naturally into a new and critical project to assess human milk for SARS-CoV-2-reactive antibodies after recovery from COVID-19. Just as New York City was shutting down in early April 2020, I put out a call on social media for study participants, which captured immense media and scientific attention. This attention allowed for a very rapid enrollment of participants into this study (currently there are over 1500 enrolled), and as many participants are local, I was able to collect pilot study samples during the shutdown and quickly optimize a SARS-CoV-2 Spike ELISA with the generous gift of proteins from the Krammer Lab. This pilot work determined there was a robust secretory IgA response in all milk samples tested, forming the basis of my recently-awarded R01, which will determine the titer and durability of the human milk immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection over time, as well as the functionality of these antibodies, including neutralization capacity and ability to elicit ADCP and mediate the alternative pathway of complement. Beyond the importance of this research to public health, I aim to determine if these milk antibodies and/or antibody-secreting cells could form the basis of a COVID-19 therapeutic for all.
We are also beginning to study the SARS-CoV-2 specific antibody response in milk after maternal COVID-19 vaccination.
If you would like to participate in this study, are in the USA, and have been infected with COVID-19, please contact us
Collaborative work with the Microbiology department to analyze the human milk immune response to seasonal influenza vaccination
In 2019 I was awarded the Department of Medicine Junior Faculty Collaborative Research Initiative Award as part of a collaboration with the Microbiology department, to investigate the antibody response in human milk to seasonal influenza vaccination. Though vaccination against influenza during pregnancy is effective at reducing rates of infant influenza virus infection, respiratory illness, and severe respiratory complications, vaccination rates in this population are suboptimal. Furthermore, depending on the timing of the pregnancy relative to the influenza season, seasonal vaccination during pregnancy may not be possible. For these reasons, vaccinating against influenza is recommended postpartum to provide a “cocooning effect”, such that the mother is less likely to transmit influenza virus to the infant. This recommendation is also based on the assumption that influenza-specific breast milk-derived antibodies are protective for the infant, but remarkably, there is a paucity of studies definitively addressing the efficacy or function of these milk antibodies, particularly in women immunized postpartum. Therefore, my collaborative study will determine the seasonally-relevant, influenza virus-specific antibody titers and antiviral functions in the milk of women vaccinated post-partum. These data are needed to determine the utility of seasonal postpartum influenza vaccination and, if positive, can be used to encourage influenza vaccination among lactating women. Conversely, if these data show post-partum vaccination fails to generate functional influenza virus-specific milk antibodies, this would serve to strengthen a campaign to vaccinate all pregnant women against influenza virus regardless of the time of year their pregnancy occurs, and may also may facilitate development of novel influenza vaccines that specifically elicit efficacious milk antibodies (part of the maternal vaccination research project below).
If you would like to participate in this study, are in NYC, planning on getting the flu shot this season, and can provide 3+ oz of milk before and after your flu shot, contact us
Fc-mediated antibody function against HIV by relevant primary cells
RV144, the only clinical HIV vaccine trial to show significant efficacy, found that reduced infection rates correlated with non-neutralizing antibodies specific for the V2 region of the HIV Envelope, and that Fc-mediated activities including antibody-dependent cellular phagocytosis (ADCP) correlated with the level of total serum V2 antibodies. I therefore am further exploring the ADCP function of HIV-specific antibodies, and have found that human primary neutrophils exhibit a unique ADCP profile compared to more commonly-assayed but likely less relevant monocyte cell lines. Importantly, neutrophils have been highly understudied in the context of HIV transmission, particularly in the context of mother-to-child transmission (MTCT). Greater than 100,000 MTCTs of HIV via breastfeeding occur annually. However, even in the absence of antiretrovirals, only ~10-15% of infants breastfed by HIV-infected mothers become infected, suggesting a strong protective effect of the milk itself. Unless access to clean water and appropriate infant formula is reliable, the WHO does not recommend cessation of breastfeeding for HIV-infected mothers. Importantly, HIV-specific antibodies in milk have been correlated with reduced MTCT and/or infant death from HIV infection. What remains largely unclear is the contribution of the cellular fraction of human milk to its antiviral qualities. To fill a critical knowledge gap, I therefore aimed to investigate ADCP by human milk leukocytes, hypothesizing this innate immune function may play a key role in minimizing MTCT via breastfeeding. My initial studies found significant ADCP activity in milk that was mainly neutrophil-driven, again highlighting the importance of this understudied cell type. This work formed the basis of my current R21-funded project – the comprehensive study of ADCP of HIV by milk leukocytes, examining the impact of target size, antibody class, and stage of lactation.
If you would like to participate in this study, are in NYC, and can provide 3+ oz of fresh milk for a morning pickup, please contact us
Maternal vaccination aimed to specifically enhance the human milk immune response
One overarching goal of my research program is to ultimately design vaccines with protection of infants and young children through breastfeeding in mind. This has been enormously overlooked across the entire field of vaccine design, as mentioned above with reference to influenza. With regards to COVID-19, even when there is a licensed vaccine, vaccine efficacy in terms of protection via breastfeeding by a vaccinated mother will have been largely uninvestigated even if lactating mothers are encouraged to get this novel vaccine. My COVID-19 project detailed above will ultimately allow for a detailed comparison between the human milk immune response to SARS-CoV-2 infection and vaccination. The involvement of our division with the Pfizer vaccine trials at Sinai may facilitate my involvement in a study arm including lactating study participants, depending on upcoming trial outcomes.
In the HIV context, this research is particularly important and unique, as it is evident that although human milk is a vehicle for HIV transmission, its virus-blocking properties are significant, and there may be a role for therapeutic vaccination of HIV-infected mothers to entirely prevent MTCT via breastfeeding. As such, an initial aim of this aspect of my research program is to investigate how best to enhance the potency and function of HIV-specific antibodies in the milk of HIV-infected women, and design HIV vaccines for all women that elicit a robust milk immune response.
Though human milk antibody is ~90% IgA, nearly all in secretory (s) form (sIgA), most studies have found all HIV-specific antibodies in the milk of HIV-infected women is IgG, a finding which extends to non-human primate (NHP) experiments. This surprising finding presents an “area for improvement” wherein it may be possible to prevent this route of MTCT entirely by enhancing milk sIgA specificity toward a high proportion of HIV-reactive Abs using a maternal vaccination regimen targeting the gut associated lymphoid tissue (GALT), the origin tissue of the B cells that ultimately produce milk sIgA (known as the entero-mammary link). NHPs, particularly Rhesus Macaques (RMs), are an obvious choice for pre-clinical work in this area, given their extensive use in the HIV field; however, the entero-mammary link has not been verified or analyzed in NHPs. As such, it is critical to determine if an entero-mammary link exists in NHPs, and to fully describe this link prior to embarking on a targeted maternal vaccination program. This is the subject of a pending R21 grant using RMs housed at the California National Primate Research Center (CNPRC) at UC Davis, which will compare: the sequences of immunoglobulin genes amplified from B cells isolated from GALT, respiratory mucosa, mammary tissue, milk, and blood; the reactivity profile of recombinant antibodies produced from these genes to a panel of enteric antigens; and the cellular homing receptor/adhesion marker profiles of B cells isolated from these various compartments. Should the proposed analysis demonstrate a clear link between gut and mammary B cells in RMs, we would proceed with immunogenicity and protection studies aimed to induce HIV-specific sIgA in milk via maternal vaccination targeting the GALT. Should the proposed study fail to demonstrate a significant entero-mammary link in RMs, further analyses could examine other NHPs such as baboons or orangutans, to determine if they are a better model for such studies, or if no NHP model is suitable. Importantly, targeted maternal vaccination for the enhancement of the milk antibody response has implications for various pathogens far beyond HIV, as detailed regarding influenza and COVID-19 above, and this proposed research is applicable in a much larger context.